Both Tom and Butch compete for the Golden Fez in the United Mouse Catchers when they both attempt to capture Jerry.

When Hildie gets a magic mirror that predicts the future, Tom sees predictions of himself being fed a fish, which is good, and then a bad prediction: switching heads with Beatie.

The witch sisters both commemorate the passing of their mother and Tom tries to help out by bringing her back from the grave.

Tom and Jerry are sent out to go retrieve an ingredient for the witch sisters by sundown before they are turned into frogs, but Tom develops a crush on Princess Toodles. Butch does, too, so they compete against each other in games to win her love while Jerry tries desperately to retrieve the ingredient himself.