The day after a police sting to catch a drug lord goes disastrously wrong, the events of the night before are reconstructed by the accounts of three police officers: Harvey Bullock, Renee Montoya, and a rookie.

A convict turned witness disappears and Harvey Bullock, who arrested him, is suspected in the incident.

Batman investigates sightings of an apparent werewolf.

Batman intervenes in a gang war and tries to convince the older of two rival bosses to change his ways.