The ghostly Puritan judge Hebediah Grim begins judging the young women of Crystal Cove. The gang initially suspects Ethan, believing him to be working with Gary to save girls from fake monster attacks. They investigate, but Ethan is cleared after he saves them from Grim. Grim continues to judge, and the gang comes to suspect drama student Doogle McGuineness. However, Grim attacks when the gang goes to confront Doogle. Brad and Judy offer to help trap Grim. They succeed, revealing there to be two Grims–Ethan and Gary. Daphne and Fred reveal they still like each other, while Nettles and Stone begin dating. Elsewhere, Cassidy spies on the gang, Brad, and Judy.